A year ago, the Quakes seemed dead in the water. Arena’s appointment, while intriguing, teetered on the verge of being a mistake.
With the team’s hot start, it now appears that last season was a trial run, one to build for the success of this season thus far.
Comparing this season’s side to the one that fell to the bottom of the West shows two entirely different sides. After a year of tinkering with a strange-fitting side, Arena finally got a chance to play with a team in his mold.
Saying that last season felt like a lost year seems harsh, but Arena clearly felt the same way. You can see this in player turnover. Almost the entire team that started last year’s season is gone.

The way Arena built this squad resembles that of his previous sides in both LA and New England. Outside of one player, the team remains composed of MLS veterans and a few interesting young pieces. In fact, Arena set this squad up in a similar fashion as the Vancouver Whitecaps, one of the West’s best teams last year.
No other team in MLS improved year over year quite like the Quakes.
While the season remains young, the proof of concept is really starting to bear out.
After the failure of yet another project, the Quakes found themselves in quite a familiar spot two off-seasons ago. The decision to appoint Arena rather than go for another risky bet showed how desperate the organization was for a return to normalcy.
With a front office clearly on the hot seat, every move reeked of desperation. Bringing in Cristian Arango and Josef Martinez showed an organization committed to a playoff appearance. Strangely enough, outside the Romney trade, the majority of those moves worked.
The issue that quickly arose was how to build a cohesive unit out of these players. Arena managed to get the offense to truly hum at times, with Martinez turning back the years and Espinoza playing like an All-Star. The midfield, too, with the combination of Harkes and Leroux, looked incredibly promising.
With a backline leaking goals at an almost historic rate, Arena failed to balance the team’s high-power offense with an average backline. Needing to play a formation that he never really used, it was clear that he was a little out of his depth.
Even as the team floundered in the summer, no real changes came until the end of the season. No transfers arrived either, meaning the front office and manager seemed content to ride the season out. Ultimately, all parties decided that the 2025 season was a lost one; nothing could be done to salvage it.
Towards the end of the season, with any hopes of the playoffs completely gone, the manager slowly began to prepare for this year. This, mostly, came in the form of the backline, with both Max Floriani and Reid Roberts getting good runs of play. Munie had already broken into the starting lineup by this point, and now the manager focused on finding his partner for the following season.
When the season ended, the front office was completely restructured, meaning that Arena finally had full control. A year of stumbling around for some glimmer of hope finally came to an end with the team yet again needing a reset.
With four wins out of five, no other MLS team revived itself like the Quakes.
Finally playing a formation and system he feels comfortable with, Arena built a competent lineup.
Most MLS sides that see this much improvement over the course of one offseason bring in players who drastically improve the team. The lack of transfers should have come as no surprise. After all, letting go of Chris Leitch meant that the team would be operating with a new front office.
Timo Werner’s addition surprised many and was quite a promising move, but his transfer is not the reason the Quakes are good. Arena clearly identified players who fit within his system.
On paper, the lineup set every week thus far looks less talented than the most utilized one last season. Gone are the likes of Arango and Espinoza, who provided the team with the high-level talent that they lack this season. In their place, however, Arena found a system that gets the most out of MLS players.
Beating Vancouver on Saturday, the Quakes essentially faced the club that they are modeling. Outside of their star German players, both teams primarily feature MLS veterans. Using players with plenty of experience in the league makes the transition to a new system easier.

Furthermore, the current formation selected by Arena mirrors that of the one he used in New England. A 4-2-3-1 built around a talented number ten, but the one twist this time around is the emphasis on the wingers. Given the glut of talented wide players currently rostered, it made sense to place emphasis on the width rather than a number ten.
After spending a season trying to get the most out of a squad that fit poorly together, Arena finally got his chance to play his way. Using a system he clearly feels comfortable with, the Quakes resemble a team that could compete in the playoffs.
In the span of a few months, the fortunes of Arena’s side went from incredibly grim to promising. With Werner yet to be fully integrated into the team, they’re playing with house money given how well they’ve started the season.
If Arena’s changes continue to bear fruit, a playoff appearance feels likely.




