As Timo Werner continues to ease his way into his new life in MLS, Arena will soon have quite a decision to make. With so much going well for the Quakes, integrating their most high profile signing requires some delicate tinkering.
Be it a tactical or personnel change, the manager will soon need to make a choice.
Werner’s cameos thus far show the potential of this side, as seen with the German international. While he is yet to score, his playmaking promises to be a difference-maker for the side.
Making a formation change seems unwise, given how well the wingers elevate the team. The only real option for changing the formation is perhaps to play with two strikers. Unfortunately, this means the Taskiris experiment likely ends.

A personnel change feels much more likely, with the German coming in for a number of potential players. One of the interesting wrinkles of Werner’s cameos comes from Arena using him as a winger. This seems to foreshadow him replacing Ricketts, but it doesn’t remove the possibility of the forward starting in place of Judd or Tsakiris.
Right now, the Quakes are playing with house money; they found success without Werner.
However, to truly make this squad playoff-ready, they will need their German star.
Perhaps the biggest change for the Quakes this season comes in the form of their formation. Moving away from the 3-4-3 to a more traditional 4-2-3-1 has worked wonders for the team.
Possessing an absurd amount of talented players in the wider positions, Arena doubled down on them. While they may not be the best player every matchday, the threat posed by the wingers and fullbacks unlocks everything for the team. Anything and everything runs through them.
In his brief cameos, Werner gravitated out wide; in fact, his assists came from crosses or passes made to the forward in the box. Using the free space vacated on the wings or under Judd, the German found enough room to operate in. With the wingers constantly crashing in the box, it becomes easier for Werner to pick out the right pass.
With every threat coming from out wide, Arena needs to make sure that this advantage isn’t compromised. Other areas of the formation may benefit from positional changes, but not the wingers.
The combination that seems likely to be modified with Werner easing into this squad is the number ten and striker. Judd continues to play an important role, as the first line of defense, constantly pressuring the opponent’s backline. Tsakiris, however, remains the same talented player who is yet to fully find his footing in MLS.
Should Arena consider changing the formation? Playing with two strikers makes the most sense for this roster. Pairing Judd with Werner gives the team two targetmen who approach chances differently. Werner offers the team more of a quasi-attacking midfielder role, while Judd plays as a more traditional striker.
Rather than wholesale changes for the Quakes’ formation, a slight tweak, if any, may help get the most out of Werner’s addition. A potential fix is to shift the striker partnership, but it seems unlikely that Arena will make such changes.
If Arena ends up making some adjustments, keeping the formation but replacing certain players feels likely.
Given how well the Quakes started the season with this formation, the team should do everything it can to stick with it.
While Werner is yet to score, he flashed enough playmaking potential to suggest he could replace Tsakiris. At previous stints, the German worked best alongside another striker who pulled defenses away from him—especially strikers in the mold of Judd, physical presences that can bully opponents.
At Leipzig, Werner formed a prolific partnership with Yussuf Poulsen that combined the strengths of both players. Poulsen remained a threat in a multitude of ways, which meant teams couldn’t place specific pressure on Werner. In turn, this attention opened the game up for Werner as both a scorer and a change creator.
For all the attention paid to his goalscoring prowess, Werner was always an underrated playmaker. Allowing him to operate in this role may be the Quakes’ best option at maintaining this hot start.
In the game against Philadelphia, Arena pushed Werner on the left, replacing Ricketts. For his part, the fullback turned winger started the season on fire. Werner also played well in that spot, benefiting from Jones’ presence.
As Ricketts continues to prove that he is a better winger than fullback, a fully realized version of this Quakes’ team would feature both him and Werner. Bouda, too, has finally found form in MLS, making it hard to justify Werner’s inclusion in the starting lineup over those two. Putting the German alongside these talented wingers allows them to compete at the highest level.
For Arena, one choice promises to define the Quakes’ season with Werner.
Whether to give the Judd-Werner partnership a chance or see what the team has in Tsakiris will hang over this team.
Still playing with found money, the Quakes’ hot start allows them to slowly bring Werner into the fold.
As Arena figures out his side, various factors may force his hand. Fortunately for the Quakes, a formula is slowly taking shape.




