As preseason games continue to kick off, the Quakes prepare for next season without any real additions. Despite losing key players, the team hopes Timo Werner’s addition will keep them afloat in the play-in race.
With external additions looking less likely, Arena sees internal development as the best bet.
In what may end up being one of the more depressing offseasons, key components were ripped out without replacements. Last season also proved that they needed more help, but with these losses, the issues underlying this roster only got larger.
Towards the end of last season, as injuries stacked up, Arena moved towards a youth revolution. While not the revolution envisioned by previous front offices, the manager bet on the development of recent draft picks or more experienced academy players. Beau Leroux stole the show last year, but Daniel Munie’s development shows how Arena may operate.

The last great Quakes team, the 2012 Supporters Shield winners, saw their season come to an end at the hands of Arena’s Galaxy side. Built on MLS veterans who were entering their prime, that team took the MLS by surprise. Perhaps paying homage to this team is the only way Arena can get it to make a play-in push.
With a little less than a month remaining until MLS returns, Arena may have the toughest assignment of his career on his hands.
In the span of a few weeks, the manager needs to build a team that struggled to be competitive last year.
Despite a number of academy players departing over the past month, there’s little doubt that younger players will have a large impact next season. The lack of any additional transfers, outside the blockbuster Werner one, only solidifies the importance placed on them.
Looking back to that game against San Diego, the defensive performance put on by a relatively inexperienced backline impressed. The trio of Floriani, Munie, and Roberts took advantage of their opportunity to solidify themselves as first-team players. With only Dave Romney remaining as one of the veteran defenders, that trio will surely play a large role this season.
Under Arena, Munie finally received the playing time that he needed to prove himself as a true starting-caliber center back. Should Arena continue to use the 3-4-3 formation, Munie fills that role of the central defender quite well. While his passing ability lacks anything truly elite, the midfield in front of him helps cover up some of those warts.
Unlike both Floriani and Munie, Reid Roberts saw a small amount of playing time. Having only just been drafted, Arena opted to play it safe with Roberts. However, given how teams targeted Romney last season, Roberts is likely to play more this upcoming season.
As the Quakes sputtered last summer, Floriani began to play more of a role in place of Rodrigues. With the Brazilian struggling with injuries and poor performances, the youngster stepped up, showing the ability to match his production.
Romney, being the last veteran center back option on the roster, bodes ill for any hopes for a play-in push. Even if Arena and the front office truly believe in this defense, they’ve left little room for error.
Using the game against San Diego as an example, there is hope in Arena getting this group of young defenders to be actual difference makers.
With a thin roster, this bet desperately needs to pay off.
The hallmark of that Quakes team, which won the 2012 Supporters Shield, came in the way the squad was built. Featuring mostly MLS vets and journeymen, they took the league by surprise, powered by their mercurial striker, Chris Wondolowski.
Unfortunately for Quakes’ fans, the magic of that 2012 will likely never be replicated again. MLS continues to evolve, making the game almost unrecognizable. Scouting and managing have changed so much in the past 14 years.
This squad, despite some delusional hopes, is not built for a title run. Instead, the team needs to use the 2012 squad as an example to stay alive in the play-in race. In this current squad, there exist shades of that team, with some notable differences.
While the high-end talent favors the 2026 team, the MLS veterans on the roster resemble those of the Shield-winning team. The midfield and offense, outside the supposed Werner signing, reflect that tilt towards MLS veterans.

Not including Beau Leroux, Arena can field a team composed almost entirely of MLS veterans. Last season, this gave them a decent foundation, keeping them from being a total wreck. For all the help it gave them, it didn’t raise their ceiling.
What the Quakes continue to miss is that top-end talent, which could be aided by the vets on the roster. The addition of Werner, along with Arango’s resignation, gives the team more all-star-level talent, but they can only go so far as the rest of the roster takes them. Just as in 2012, the ceiling of this squad runs through the collection of MLS vets that Arena continues to bring in.
One of the best aspects of Arena’s tenure thus far has come from his transfer strategy. Bringing in seasoned MLS players gives the team a floor it lacked in seasons past.
Barring any other large transfers, the Quakes’ best hope lies in internal development. Granted, the team possesses certain players who seem likely to make developmental jumps; their veterans may make or break this season.
If the team truly hopes to make a push for the play-in, so much needs to break right.




