Despite losing their captain, the San Jose Earthquakes seem to be on the verge of their largest signing. Almost a decade ago, Timo Werner stood as one of the most promising strikers in Europe.

While his career never reached the lofty expectations placed on him, his addition would mean plenty to the Quakes.


As more news comes out regarding Espinoza’s departure, the vibes around the Quakes couldn’t be lower. From Chris Leitch supposedly forgetting to extend the Argentine to Espinoza turning down the Quakes’ offer, they desperately need some hope.

Reported by Fabrizio Romano, Werner appears to be heading towards the Bay for quite a decent fee. With the rest of the league making moves for European players in Werner’s image, the Quakes finally join a large trend. Making a move of this type allows the Quakes to finally land another top cornerstone.

On paper, this move makes sense for the team both on and off the pitch. Even though he never became the player that Chelsea expected, the German was still an international player who won multiple trophies. Concerns, however, arise from his fit alongside Arango and this Quakes team.


San Jose bringing in Werner, despite losing Espinoza, gives both the team and fanbase a shot in the arm.

The German is unlikely to truly transform the team, but he clearly profiles as an MLS All-Star.


When he moved to Chelsea in the summer of 2020, Werner had already become one of the most prolific strikers in Europe. Lighting up the Bundesliga with Red Bull Leipzig, the German prepared to take over Europe.

Unfortunately for the striker, the Chelsea number nine curse struck. Instead of being the future for both Chelsea and the German national team, Werner joined a long list of Chelsea forwards who could never find form in the Premier League. His struggles in front of the goal failed to stop Chelsea from winning the Champions League.

After failing to secure the number nine spot in England, he returned to Germany with Leipzig. The return to Germany and a later loan to Tottenham failed to revive his career. In fact, Werner never reached a 10-goal season after his first stint with Leipzig.

By 2026, Werner stood on the fringes of the club that he meant so much to. With only three appearances and no goals scored, the German’s time amongst Europe’s top leagues has finally run out.

In recent seasons, clubs across MLS made bets on these types of players, those with plenty of European experience who are on their way out. Take, for example, Atlanta United’s Aleksei Miranchuk, whose profile never matched that of Werner, but they had similar careers. The Russian cooked his home league before finding success in Italy, before moving to the States.

While the modus operandi of the Quakes under Arena and Leitch revolved around MLS veterans, betting on players like Werner fits the direction of the league. The hope for the Quakes with Werner is that he may replicate the impact of Anders Dreyer with San Diego FC. These players represent not home runs, like Mueller or Son, but rather those extra-base hits that lift teams into the playoffs.


At the start of the decade, few players matched the hype surrounding Werner.

Perhaps the most interesting aspect of the German’s career is that he failed to live up to expectations, but won so many trophies.


The move for Werner helps the team elevate its profile on the pitch, but his fit within the squad remains a little strange. Additionally, if the team truly feels that now is the time to compete, this can’t be the only move.

Credit: Fabrizio Romano-Twitter/X

Unlike the other European players mentioned earlier, Werner arrives in MLS at arguably the lowest point of his career. With only 11 league goals scored in the past, his record doesn’t really inspire hope in his addition to the side. Comparing him to Dreyer is a little unfair, given that the Dane was the best player in the Belgian league for multiple seasons.

If the Quakes hope that the German will see a revival as a scorer, they may be betting on the wrong horse. In fact, as his career experienced various highs and lows, Werner’s play style evolved. 

In his last season in the Premier League with Tottenham, the German showed an ability to play as an offensive hub rather than a pure striker. Postecoglu used him as a spoke, which played into his ability to pass pretty well for a striker—having wingers play off him and letting Son operate as the true striker allowed for Werner to remain productive.

The issue for the Quakes is that Arango plays a very similar role for the Quakes. Under Arena last season, the striker played as a quasi-left winger, creating for Martinez. In that front three, the manager wanted Arango to be a secondary playmaker rather than the main threat.

Adding Werner into the mix doesn’t allow for Martinez or Werner to be their go-to target. If Arena decides to play them as a striker in a two-man front line, it may work, but returning to a front three robs them of a real threat. Additionally, with Espinoza’s absence, the attack remains imbalanced.


Werner papers over some cracks on this team, but there are too many issues remaining to feel confident in this side.

Furthermore, his addition necessitates some changes on Arena’s part.


Moving for Werner shows a team finally accepting where the league is trending towards and trying to meet the moment. While it remains an imperfect fit, these are the sort of gambles that may help the team vault out of the basement.

As exciting as this addition promises to be, there still remains plenty of work for this team as the preseason nears.


 

Comments are closed.

Check Also

A New Day in San Jose: John Fisher Out, Private Equity In

On the eve of their first home playoff game at PayPal Park, one of the most monumental mom…