11-2; so, what?

Yeah, yeah, yeah, tell me something I don’t know about the Patriots and Broncos being 11-2. It’s the same story with both teams; don’t get me wrong, I admire their teams and records. Tell me this, now remove their starting quarterback(s) for 6-7 weeks, ditch both their starting defensive players in the first 5 weeks, and then tell me that they’ll still have the same record.
I bet you can’t with a straight face admit that those 11-2 teams would have the same record, let alone a winning one at 9-4, which is where 49ers stalwart coach Kyle Shanahan has his 49ers positioned. Given the 49ers’ record and the amount of mounting injuries throughout the season, it is enough reason to give the Coach of the Year award to Coach Shanahan.
Still not convinced? Just wait.
Is this Kyle Shanahan’s BEST year as #49ers head coach?
Per @DMRussini, Shanahan is coaching the season of his life — and it’s hard to argue.
Despite nonstop chaos in 2025:
• Stars dropping (Bosa, Warner)
• Purdy, Kittle, Pearsall all missed time
• Aiyuk hasn’t played a… pic.twitter.com/AD57FnBBAP— 49ers & NFL News 24/7 (@49ersSportsTalk) November 29, 2025
The Straw That Stirs the Drink
Helping Shanahan along the way to unimagined heights is the engine that keeps the 49ers’ offense trucking along in the league. Christian McCaffrey deserves to be a part of the 2025 NFL MVP discussions while leading all running backs in most categories and is inching towards a 2nd possible 1,000/1,000 season (both receiving and rushing).
All of this while having to deal with an offense spiraling out of control, given their recent injuries to George Kittle, Ricky Pearsall, and, most importantly, the dilemma with diva receiver Brandon Aiyuk.
Oh, and I forgot to mention that the 49ers were without their starting quarterback for a third of the season, and who was the anchor of the offense, you may have asked, and that’s Christian McCaffrey.
Christian McCaffrey is having a historic season. Some of his stats at his bye:
🏈McCaffrey now has a league-leading 1,655 scrimmage yards this season, 849 rushing and 806 receiving. He’s the third player in NFL history with at least 800 rush yards and 800 receiving yards in his… pic.twitter.com/ZSCczJVAIk
— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) December 2, 2025
Why They Won’t Win
Oh, the 49ers are winning, and I don’t see them stopping anytime soon, but Shanahan and McCaffrey may nothing be so lucky taking home individual trophies this season. You have a mounting list of possible MVP candidates this season, especially when the league loves to coddle teams most with a league-leading record, hence the Rams, Broncos, and Patriots. All three of those teams’ quarterbacks, Stafford, Maye, and Nix, are destined to be frontrunners for the award, as we all know the league clamors over its quarterbacks.
In reality, the workhorse of a given team would have to be CMC, which sometimes alone accounts for up to 40% of the team’s total output. Shanahan will follow the same fate as he superstar running back, and most likely won’t win coach of the year, given the records of the Denver Broncos and New England Patriots, both already guiding their teams to 11-2 records.
If you keep reading, I’ll tell you why it’s not so important.
Ranking NFL MVP candidates: Matthew Stafford vs. Drake Maye – via @ESPN App https://t.co/TKs6oT8C6m
— Erin (@RailWriting) December 14, 2025
There’s Only 1 Trophy That Matters
If anything, 49ers and fans alike will take hollow awards along the way, but the most important award or individual trophy they really care about is the Vince Lombardi. Why is it important?
Well, such a win, leading a team to its 6th championship, may not seem like a big deal. Still, it’s everything to Shanahan, as it gives him the validation he needs to be regarded as one of the best coaches in the NFL, even though he’s already regarded as such.
Time will tell.




