In perhaps their best game of the season, the Quakes traveled down to San Diego to deny them the Supporters’ Shield. Despite some changes across the team, everyone played almost perfectly to grab an impressive win.

For as good as the performance felt, the inability to string consistent play marred the team.


Among all the aspects of an organization, analyzing the roles of team members in the team’s success can be difficult. For the Quakes, some performed at the level required, others struggled in Arena’s system, and a select few pulled the team down. 

Players like Arango and Espinoza performed at an All-Star level, putting the team on their backs. However, perhaps the most impressive play came from Beau Leroux, cementing himself as a key piece for the future. No matter the changes that the Quakes seem likely to experience over the next few months, enough players emerged as worthy to keep on.

Credit: San Jose Earthquakes

Inconsistency marred the Quakes all season, at almost every position. From injuries to drop-offs, the players failed to truly establish any sort of momentum. This, perhaps more than any truly terrible performance, hurt the team.


The players who took the field each matchday attempted to implement Arena’s vision.

To the best of their abilities, they tried to, but the contradictions within the system proved too much to overcome. 


With Josef Martinez’s revival stealing the headlines, the emergence of Beau Leroux went under the radar. While plenty of others played well, their success represented the aspect of Arena’s vision that worked.

No other Quakes impressed more than Leroux. The second-year player rose from an afterthought last season to the best midfielder that the team has seen in years. Under Arena, he emerged as one of the more promising box-to-box players in MLS.

Leroux raised the midfield standard alongside his partner, Ian Harkes. The two of them provided the team with a floor of consistent creativity. No other portion of the team saw such a jump in play as the midfield, thanks to those two. 

Another consistent performer, who helped the team’s floor, is another potential departure, Daniel. The Brazilian, who missed time due to injury, continued his run as one of the league’s best keepers. 

Despite another season as one of MLS’ top creative forces, Espinoza ended the season on a whimper. Finishing the season with just a hair under ten assists, the winger tried his best to create for an inconsistent attack. Of all the forwards, only Espinoza gave the team hope week by week, which makes his potential departure all the more disappointing.

For the Quakes, the positives tie into the negatives. Arena possessed players whose play transformed the side into one that resembled a professional side, rather than a mess. However, the number of times that this team showed up barely mattered.


Going into next season, a foundation exists for however the side will shake up.

The only issue is how to get this side to show up consistently.


If this season could be encapsulated in one word, it’d be inconsistent. Every time they showed signs of a playoff team, the next week they’d return to being bottom dwellers.

Outside of Dave Romney, who grew into the team’s weak link, the rest of the backline suffered from a lack of stability. Wilson barely stayed healthy, while Rodrigues saw his role both change and diminish over the course of the season. With Arena barely showing any trust in other options, the backline, once again, became the team’s Achilles heel.

Even as Daniel Munie showed that he could help anchor a defense, Arena was slow to accept that. His developmental stall, especially as the backline sank, only compounded the team’s issues. Once Arena accepted the mixture of Munie and youngsters, the issues didn’t dissipate, but they were given much-needed experience.

After Ricketts started the season so well, Arena immediately moved back to Costa, who brought veteran experience to the team. However, Costa still only really played at a starting or slightly below-starting level, meaning there was no real upgrade.

Josef Martinez, quite convincingly, disproved the washed allegations, leading the Quakes in goals scored. While the former MVP proved to be a shrewd piece of business, his goals came either in bunches or weeks apart. This would be fine had the striker been the team’s twelfth man, but he needed to show up every week for this team to have a chance.  

With the front office bringing Arango for a decent fee, much was expected from the former LAFC man. Due to the lack of a real left winger, the Colombian played most of the season out of position. Finishing with a respectable 13 goals, Arango still struggled with consistent form, especially during that two-month winless streak.


For certain aspects of the team, there exists hope that some form can reappear next season.

With Arango moved to his preferred position and a sensible defense, the team is more coherent.


On the field, despite some terrible performances, the players showed glimpses of a good team. One that revolves around a dynamic midfield and potent defense.

However, Arena and the team need to find a way to ensure this team appears consistently.


 

Comments are closed.

Check Also

A New Day in San Jose: John Fisher Out, Private Equity In

On the eve of their first home playoff game at PayPal Park, one of the most monumental mom…