Barring an unexpected playoff run, the San Jose Earthquakes likely end the season in a manner all too familiar to fans. Potentially another year without a playoff appearance means that change will come again in the winter.
Heading into the offseason, however, the team possesses a number of players who could form the spine of next year’s team.
Arena’s appointment promised to make this side a play-in team at a minimum. Failing to reach the postseason with yet another manager implies that the structure is weak.
No matter what happens at the managerial level, whether Arena stays, Leitch has pieces for next week. With the revelations of Beau Leroux and Daniel Munie, they finally saw some young pieces start to pop. The duo of Arango and Espinoza additionally gives them great complementary pieces for a fully realized side.

With that said, the team remains full of players who don’t fit onto winning sides in the league. Replacing these players should be the goal of the offseason. Additionally, a few players whom they acquired last offseason promise to be nothing more than luxuries for the future.
Missing out on the playoffs yet again depresses the excitement that the team built in the early stages.
However, if complemented well, there exists a spine of players who could elevate this team next season.
The emergence of a few players turned this season from one of despair to fleeting hope. To Arena’s credit, he clearly identified potential game changers for the team.
No player won fans over quite like Beau Leroux. The 2024 MLS SuperDraft pick spent last season with the Town FC, with little hope for a path to the first team. Arena clearly realized that he could fit in well as a box-to-box midfielder.
Whatever the midfield looks like next season, Leroux needs to be at the heart of it. Giving him adequate partners, potentially Vieira helps here, must be one of the goals of the offseason. The presumptive rookie of the year winner can be the midfield piece that they’ve spent a decade chasing.
Daniel Munie, in recent weeks, also emerged as a potential long-term fit in the backline. Paired with other starting-level center backs, it’s easy to imagine him being part of an elite defense.
It should go without saying that Espinoza deserves to keep his role going into next season. Bringing back Arango and playing him at the striker spot gives the team two all-star-level players in attack. Additionally, the pairing gives the front office a chance to focus on bringing in that long-desired left winger to elevate the offense.
Similar to the Leroux emergence, the Quakes, for the first time in a decade, possess a decent fullback battery. Deep at both positions, the starters, Costa and Jones, profile as above-average starters capable of carrying creative responsibilities. Ricketts, for his part, is a good understudy for Costa and should be seen as his successor.
On this Quakes’ side, there is a group of players who could contribute to a playoff-caliber team.
However, it may require a new manager or tactical idea to unlock it.
A team looking to make any sort of playoff appearance can’t carry players who can’t start in the postseason. Additionally, a balanced roster that gives every player a clear role is necessary.
The backline requires the most attention, given the hope that Arena’s hiring would help address. Much has been made about Dave Romney’s regression into a bench player, but the issue is deeper. Despite both Rodrigues and Wilson having their strengths, it seems neither has fully won the trust of the manager.
Injuries played their part, but both players spent time over the past two seasons trying to win their spots. While Rodrigues plays more games, Wilson is clearly the better player and fits on a winning team. If the team needs to make a decision on both of them, keeping the Portuguese makes more sense.
The midfield brings a strange predicament. For the first time in years, the team employs starting-caliber players, but they may be too good for the bench.
Despite being projected as a starter to begin the season, Mark Anthony Kaye became a solid bench player. If Arena decides to move Vieira into the Harkes spot, then it adds another starting-caliber player to the bench. However, out of all the problems for the team to deal with, this is probably the best to leave as is.
One of the questions likely to hound the front office this offseason is what to do with Josef Martinez. The Quakes’ joint top scorer, it feels unlikely that the team will bring him back alongside Arango. Despite clearly being a playoff player, the team would truly need him to become that super sub like he was in Montreal.
To build a playoff-caliber team, Leitch will have to confront the state of the team. A mixture of players who are either not starting caliber or luxuries; how he addresses this will define the team.
Over the course of the season, Arena’s side showed glimmers of hope. To push the Quakes to the next level, Leitch needs to give this team yet another makeover.
This will include making important decisions on a number of players.



