In the wake of Matias Almeyda’s dismissal, the San Jose Earthquakes decided to go in a different direction.
Tapping into the immense pool of local talent and their own academy, the Quakes hoped that a youth movement would follow. However, as the season heads towards its end, that dream seems to be gone.
Bringing Arena always meant a compromise for the front office. Yes, the team stood better prepared to make the playoffs, but player development needed to take a backseat.
Players like Cruz Medina and Niko Tsakiris went from key pieces for the future to permanent bench fixtures. The only young players to really feature for Arena have been more defensive-minded players or those with more experience. Even Beau Leroux, the favorite for Rookie of the Year, was a college player who spent last season with The Town FC.

Leitch and his front office brought in Arena to break the team’s playoff rut.
If the Quakes miss out, which seems likely, what was the purpose of throwing away youth development?
As the league continues to make that a priority, the Quakes can’t afford to lag behind.
After their success with Cade Cowell, another future existed where the team better integrated their academy.
While it may still happen, this season seems to have severely hurt that pipeline.
When Alex Covelo started to incorporate Niko Tsakiris into the first team in 2022, a new future appeared on the horizon. One that attempted to build the team’s success through their academy.
While Almeyda ultimately failed in the Bay, his trust in Cowell gave the club a much-needed boost. Outside of Tommy Thompson, who by that point had become a bench player, Cowell promised to be their first chance at a homegrown star. Cowell never reached star status with the Quakes, but he opened the door for others.
After Almeyda, the front office seemed to operate with the mindset that the future of the Quakes lay in their academy. Philadelphia Union’s model of mixing proven MLS talent with an exciting youth pipeline appeared to be the team’s game plan.
Part of the reason as to why the Luchi move made sense was his success with bringing academy players to the first team. His hiring reflected the front office’s new vision of a club whose success was rooted in local talent. While the manager eventually struggled as a tactician, Luchi’s vision of a successful team and academy felt alive.
After losing some academy products who starred elsewhere, most notably Diego Luna, the team became determined to avoid that. Any promising young player, no matter how far from the first team they seemed, had a contract offered. This momentum continued throughout the offseason, seeming to hint that this would be the team’s calling card in 2025.
However, this proved not to be the case. Few academy products found their paths to the first team, with Tsakiris being the only one solidly in the first team. Even Tsakiris barely features, almost completely frozen out of Arena’s plans.
For the Quakes, the success of Cowell needed to be the bridge to a new era.
It appeared to be, for a minute, but it has all fallen apart.
Despite the concerns with sacrificing long-term success for immediate success, the reasoning behind the Arena hiring makes sense. The Quakes desperately needed some sort of playoff run to boost morale.
To be fair to Arena, everything outside of player development, in terms of moves, has worked. The transfers made by the manager elevated this team’s floor to that of a competent MLS side. While things fell off for the team this summer, Arena continues to show his eye for talent.
Placing a playoff appearance above all, the players required for Arena’s system were those with MLS experience. Even the younger players who featured, like Max Floriani and Reid Roberts, have plenty of college experience. Beau Leroux, the team’s best story since Cowell, played with SJSU.
Without the most talented team, the margin of error throughout the season proved to be extremely thin. However, if the Quakes miss the playoffs, what was the point of this?

The almost complete disregard of the academy remains striking, especially with the team’s slide. Niko Tsakiris started as a rotation player at the start of the season, but is now a bench player. It sends a strange message to players in the academy.
Again, the issue at the heart of all this remains the same: the team isn’t good enough to make the playoffs and doesn’t have the space for youngsters. It is also fair to point out that the team doesn’t currently possess an academy product good enough to break through. For as good as Tsakiris promised to be, he may just be a bench player.
The contradiction between what the team needs and wants is responsible for part of the mess this season. Prioritizing immediate success and falling only sets them back more.
When that brief path forward appeared following the Almeyda era, the Quakes felt ready to take the next step. Some gains were made during that time, but not enough.
Now the team looks ready to miss out on the playoffs yet again, with no future.




