Hoping for any sort of positive result, the Quakes entered Levi’s with a new look.

After some tinkering in recent weeks, Arena opted to play a new formation against LAFC. Deviating from the formation that stabilized them proved to be insufficient to stopping a red hot LA team.


Given how excellent LAFC continues to be down the stretch, it makes sense that Arena wanted to mitigate that potent offense. By playing a somewhat more conservative lineup than the usual 3-4-3, the manager put all his eggs in limiting the ways their offense could cut the Quakes apart.

Rather than utilizing a three-man backline to contain LAFC’s front three, Arena played a sort of makeshift back four. With Jones out, the manager played Rodrigues at the right back spot, which gave the team some continuity. However, the center back pairing proved to be too weak. 

Even the typically strong midfield saw changes in an attempt to negate LAFC’s buildup play. The pairing of Harkes and Leroux became one of the season’s best stories. With the transfer of Vieira, the midfield seemed primed for a change, but this game wasn’t the one for it. 


If the team hopes to make an actual push for the playoffs, measures will get more desperate.

It’s understandable that the team attempts new things at this moment, but too much change can undo progress.


Despite LAFC being a little further down the table than expected, they remain the favorites to come out of the Western Conference. The addition of Son Heung-min took a talented squad and made them the strongest team in the league.

Any manager entering this game would need to game plan around the trio of Bouanga, Son, and Tillman. Each player possesses the ability to kill your backline in a multitude of ways. Needing to address this, Arena opted to change the Quakes’ formation for the first time since the first quarter of the season.

Changing your formation this deep in the season, with only a few weeks left, only helps for a game or two. With such a small sample size, nothing can truly be drawn from the game for the long term.

With that said, the backline put in a disastrous performance with every aspect failing at one point or another. From the center backs letting Bouanga and Son do whatever they wanted to the fullbacks being nonexistent, nothing about this gamble really worked.

PHOTO: San Jose Earthquakes

While Munie’s performances in recent weeks inspire hope for his long-term future, his fit in a back two requires a stronger partner. Munie did make a few mistakes, which led to LAFC goals, but he seemed capable of keeping up with LAFC’s attack. Romney continued to be the weaklink, as Son targeted him specifically and without the proper cover, Son got whatever he wanted.

At times this season, Arena toyed with the idea of playing Rodrigues at right back in order to get the most out of his runs forward. The Brazilian struggled to impact the game on both sides of the ball. Unable to keep up physically with the penetrating runs, Rodrigues kept getting caught out of position.


The decision to match LAFC’s attack backfired on the Quakes.

Constantly exposed throughout the game, there was no real hope for them.


Perhaps the second-best development for the Quakes, besides their attack, has been the midfield. Beau Leroux, becoming a key contributor after not really featuring for the team last season, continues to be incredible.

Bringing in Vieira meant that some sort of tweaking to the aforementioned midfield would be required. However, it never truly made sense, despite the experience that Vieira came with. Furthermore, his fit felt awkward in Arena’s system.

In the 3-4-3 system, the midfield duo should consist of a more box-to-box player next to a deeper lying one. That midfielder playing deeper could be more of a traditional defensive midfielder or the idealized version of Jackson Yueill, the playmaker.

Vieira, theoretically, fits perfectly, but Harkes’ importance to the team makes it almost impossible to drop him. To essentially deal with this situation and create a more defensive side, Arena changed it to a midfield three.

With the move to the three-man midfield, every player filled in their desired role hypothetically. Throwing in Vieira and forcing Harkes and Leroux into a new formation clearly hurt them. While LAFC possesses one of the best midfields in the MLS, the Quakes gave up the midfield battle too easily.

Unable to win any control of the midfield, until LAFC let their foot slightly off the gas, no production came from there. Leroux still made some dangerous runs, but neither he nor Harkes ever really impacted the game. Additionally, Vieira proved too slow to contend with the speed at which LAFC attacked.

The addition of Vieira so late into this season always meant that this year would be a wash for him. Deciding to try to introduce him and a new system in such a high-pressure game could only have hurt the team, which it did.


While some positives exist from this game, especially the way Judd looks as a starter, the decision to force a new formation onto the team proved useless.

The back four failed to stop anything, and the midfield three never produced anything of note.


With the hopes of a playoff appearance diminishing by the day, these tweaks can’t and won’t save this team.


 

Comments are closed.

Check Also

A New Day in San Jose: John Fisher Out, Private Equity In

On the eve of their first home playoff game at PayPal Park, one of the most monumental mom…