In desperate need of any points, Arena rolled the dice with some key changes against the Dynamo. With the Quakes leaving with all three points, they’ve kept themselves alive in the playoff race.

However, the changes made to the starting lineup may prove crucial to the final weeks of the playoff push.


For the majority of the season, barring certain circumstances, Arena kept the same lineup. Week in, week out, the same collection of players found themselves starting.

After a poor showing against San Diego last week, the manager felt the need to shake things up. With Ronaldo Vieira finally arriving in the Bay, Arena also had the chance to play a system that could feature the new signing. The Dynamo being well below the Quakes in the standings afforded them the chance to make these adjustments.

PHOTO: San Jose Earthquakes

Not counting Ricketts getting the start, as Costa got injured during warm-ups, the rest of the changes felt very deliberate. Every move seemed to be hinting at how the team needs to look in the coming weeks. Playing with more structure and players in roles that make more sense, the Quakes looked professional against the Dynamo.


Making these sorts of granular moves in the waning weeks of the season offers too small a sample size to truly gain anything from it.

However, these moves feel like a mix of throwing the last few things at the wall and prepping for next season.


Throughout the season, the midfield saw barely any changes. The composition of the midfield featured a more defensive midfielder cleaning up for a more adventurous one.

Having played almost every game in the midfield, Leroux needed a break coming into Saturday. The favorite for Rookie of the Year, Leroux transformed the team’s midfield. Crashing into the box with threatening runs or connecting the defense to the offense, he continues to do everything.

While Harkes is typically paired with Leroux, Kaye saw an increase in playing time in recent weeks.


Providing more defensive cover, both Harkes and Kaye act as the first line of playmaking in front of the backline.


The addition of Vieira, an almost purely defensive midfielder, necessitated a change from Arena. Harkes, who played the perfect foil to Leroux as a deep-lying playmaker, saw his spot threatened in the weeks leading up to the Vieira move. In his place came Kaye to act as a defensive anchor.

Portraying Kaye as a purely defensive player is somewhat unfair to the player, given his ability to find players and organize the attack. However, his reintroduction to the side acts as the canary in the coal mine for Vieira. Arena envisions Leroux partnering with the defensive anchor, who can act as the first line of defense when the youngster bombs forward.

Harkes will continue to play a role going forward, but it seems like he will be the player who’ll rotate with Leroux. This midfield battery gives the team so many different ways to attack opponents, making it a dangerous force for the first time in years. Vieira may not be the starter next to Leroux as the season comes to its end, but going into next year, he will for sure be that player.


To truly create a balanced midfield, the team needed to find a defensive presence to throw next to Leroux.

As the team demonstrated against Houston, having an anchor in the midfield provides the team with a solid foundation. 


Despite being the most in-form striker on the team, Josef Martinez found himself relegated to the bench on Saturday. In his place started Preston Judd, who played a key role off the bench thus far this season.

Both players essentially play the same role, despite their differences in size. They occupy the same spaces as pure strikers. Neither player feels completely comfortable with a role larger than just finishing off moves.

Choosing to bench the team’s best goal threat this season certainly raised some eyebrows, but there may be some method to this madness. Judd essentially provides the team with a supercharged Kikanović performance. 

Using his size to threaten backlines in a number of ways, his runs resemble those of a striker more than Kikanović’s. As he showed throughout the season, Judd has that natural striker instinct to get in the perfect spot to rattle a shot off. By drawing the attention of the backline due to his threatening size, he offered more space to Arango, which led to the first goal for San Jose.

Moving Martinez back to the bench gives the team a real supersub in a way they really haven’t had since Alan Gordon. Yes, the former MVP continues to battle for the lead in goals for the Quakes, but he remains at his best off the bench. Being able to come into the game and pester opponents when they’re tired offers the team another dimension.

Additionally, as the stakes increase in the coming weeks, the team needs a veteran who can come off the bench and stabilize the situation. For as good as Judd has been off the bench, it’s tough to fully place trust in him as the first option off the bench. Martinez offers a totally different look that will surely complicate any defensive schemes.

Arena’s choice to move Judd into the starting lineup for Martinez should have backfired, but it presented an interesting glimpse into the team’s future. With every game mattering more and more, the team needs a veteran difference maker like Martinez.


Saturday’s game wasn’t just a good result, but also a chance to see how the team might tackle these coming weeks.

A more balanced midfield, combined with placing a veteran presence on the bench, may be what the Quakes need.


Every game from here on out needs to be treated as a must-win, and these changes may just help with that.


 

Comments are closed.

Check Also

PREVIEW: All Eyes On Houston – Earthquakes Welcome Dynamo for Historic Home Playoff

Despite a 3-1 drubbing by Minnesota, the San Jose Earthquakes finished fourth and in high …