After another middling week in MLS action, the Quakes find themselves nearer and nearer to the outside of the playoff race. Despite showing signs of improvement from last season, this team remains unable to reach the next level.
As the team continues to hit a wall, evaluations of Bruce Arena’s work will creep up.
Starting the season with the best attack in the league, the Quakes promised to deliver playoff action to PayPal Park. Bruce Arena’s arrival helped the team play like an MLS side, thanks in part to his smart transfers.
The first few months proved that Arena was the right choice, despite the concerns. An electric start buoyed by players who actually fit into the modern MLS. Sure, they still conceded, as they had in seasons past, but the attack promised to keep them afloat.

As the months drew on, the defense became too much of a concern, and Arena remained unable to fix the issue. Almost too dogmatic in his system, certain players found themselves sacrificed to the altar of the new Quakes. Numerous absences meant that the manager had to get creative, but he continues to avoid messing with his system.
By the Leagues Cup, the Quakes remain in the playoff race, despite only two wins since May.
Arena delivered the Quakes’ hope back in the first few months, but h,e to,o is floundering.
Upon joining the Quakes, Arena was made both the coach and sporting director of the team. Evaluating the US soccer icon requires measuring his performance in both areas.
Utilizing a 3-4-3 formation, Arena hedged the team’s success on balancing both sides of the action. While still a mess defensively, playing three forwards with a box-to-box midfielder elevated this team—the fluidity and speed with which the front three attack poses immense pressure on any backline.
Given the results of the front three, most attention has been paid to them, but the midfield truly is the team’s heartbeat. For the first time in close to a decade, the midfield doesn’t resemble a dumpster fire.
The duo of Harkes and Leroux so perfectly complement each other that everything runs through them. Harkes’ ability to playmake from deep and transition stages of play represents such a massive upgrade from Yueill. Leroux remains the team’s best story, with the former draft pick giving the team a dimension that they’ve lacked in the middle for years.
While the defensive issues continue to be the main boogeyman for the team, the lack of flexibility in the midst of the slide is concerning. With the same lineups picked week in and week out, fans can guess the player choices with little difficulty. This means that the team is unable to offer teams a different challenge when players miss time.
The rotation issues persist through to his substitution patterns, where they remain too formulaic. Needing more help offensively, either Bouda or Kikanović are the first names off the bench. Rarely does the manager give other players a chance to impact the game earlier on.
To his credit, Arena figured out how to build a starting eleven that can at least give the team a baseline of success.
Where the manager continues to struggle is in making adjustments when things go against him.
Similar to his work as the manager, Arena’s time as sporting director feels like a mixed bag. However, going forward, the role of sporting director seems more suitable for the icon.

Outside of Dave Romney, who profiles as the worst defender in MLS, Arena’s moves lifted the team’s floor. Bringing in MLS veterans, such as the previously mentioned Harkes and Kaye, gave Arena options that he could trust. Nick Lima, at this point in his career, promises to be nothing more than a backup, but his addition added depth to a thin backline.
However, perhaps the defining move of his tenure thus far seemed minor at the time, but it has changed the team’s style. Acting early to bring in Dejuan Jones to move Espinoza further up the pitch was a stroke of genius. Jones proved to be an excellent starting right back, allowing the team’s best players to play in their preferred roles.
Younger players whose potential lies more in the role-player zone rather than the star zone also benefit from playing under Arena. Bouda, Judd, and Leroux all found a second life under Arena by promising to be MLS contributors, if nothing more.
Unlike Luch or even Almeyda, Arena struggles with developing younger talents. However, it feels that the team prioritized returning to the playoffs over youth development. If that truly is the case, Arena has done exactly what the team asked of him.
Unfortunately for the future that Quakes spent years building towards, it seems to be in tatters. Niko Tsakiris gets the occasional cameo, despite the future being built around him, while only Max Floriani appears to have earned Arena’s trust. Despite hyping up the likes of Cruz Medina and Nick Fernandez, they seem unlikely to break out under Arena.
Should Arena continue on with the Quakes for an extended period, the role of sporting director suits him best. Clearly, he still understands what success requires in the MLS, but the only concern regarding him is developing the next batch of Quakes’ stars.
Bringing in Arena meant that the Quakes prioritized immediate success over a long-term plan. Can anyone honestly blame them, given the total failure of their previous projects?
Should the team miss the playoffs, however, Arena needs to be thoroughly evaluated for the future.
PHOTO: San Jose Earthquakes




