Schaefer is the presumed top pick in this draft class, but there is always a chance that things won’t go according to plan.
Last week, we looked at the most likely second pick in the draft, Michael Misa.
Today, we will examine Matthew Schaefer. Although unlikely, the Islanders could shock everyone and take one of the top forward prospects with their first pick.
Who is Matthew Schaefer?
Schaefer is a 17-year-old defenseman for the OHL Erie Otters. He stands at 6’2” and weighs in at 183 pounds. The lefty is classified as a speedy two-way defenseman.
This season with Erie, he has only played 17 games. Schaefer suffered a season-ending broken clavicle at the World Juniors tournament in December. In those 17 games, he had seven goals and 15 assists. This is a very small sample size, but good numbers in limited action.
What Schaefer Could Bring to San Jose

The Sharks have their goalie of the future in Yaroslav Askarov. They are also LOADED with young forwards, namely Macklin Celebrini, Will Smith, and William Eklund, just to name a few.
The Sharks lack defensive prospects, though. Shakir Mukhamadullin does look like the first defenseman to be NHL-ready. Luca Cagnoni also made his debut this past season. Sam Dickinson could also debut next season. However, outside of those three, the Sharks do not have top defenseman talent. Schaefer instantly changes that.
Mukhamadullin would be a very solid second-pair D-man. Cagnoni could play third, but he could also run the power play. Dickinson is having a record-breaking season with the OHL London Knights. He is a potential top pairing if his game can carry over to the NHL.
Schaefer would instantly shoot to the top of the defenseman prospect list. He would also have a direct line to the top defensive pair.
Will Schaefer Be Ready for Next Season?
No, again. Schaefer is still 17 until September. A fresh 18-year-old on an NHL roster is incredibly rare. On top of that, he missed most of this season with his clavicle injury. Expect Schaefer to continue his OHL career next season to allow him to develop.
Even if Schaefer is not NHL-ready, his presence in the Sharks organization would continue to fuel the team’s vision of the future.
Even though he is the top prospect in the draft, it is not a foregone conclusion that he will be picked first overall. New York moved way up in the lottery, so their vision is different from what would be expected from a last-place team.
No matter what happens, the Sharks are still picking second and will pick up a fantastic player.
Be excited, Sharks fans. The future is teal!
PHOTO: @erieotters/Instagram




