Amid yet another downward spiral, the San Jose Earthquakes made an interesting set of transfers.
Bruce Arena’s transformation of the Quakes into the New England Revolution continued with these moves.

Both transfers make some sense, but they also raise questions about what exactly will push this team up a level.


On April 23rd, the San Jose Earthquakes traded for both Noel Buck and DeJuan Jones. Both previously played under Arena in New England, but neither promises to be a game-changer.

With Arena shifting left back duties often, bringing in Jones seems to offer no ceiling raise. A more accomplished MLS player than any of his competition, he remains in the mold of them. He promises to be a more competent option at the position without any extra potential.

PHOTO: San Jose Earthquakes

The Buck move adds interesting wrinkles to this squad. Only 20 years old, the former English youth international has featured sporadically in MLS since his debut. This move intrigued most fans because he likely doesn’t start, and it seems strange that the Revolution would trade a player like this.

If the Quakes hope these moves push them out of their malaise, it’s unlikely that they become any sort of savior. These moves resemble rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic, with the chance that one of them serves as a liferaft.


In a vacuum, the Jones move makes sense.

A good starting caliber fullback who contributes well in the attack while not being a total safety cone on defense.


The US international made his name with Arena in New England before moving to Columbus last season. Forming the best fullback tandem in MLS with Tajon Buchanan, Jones burst into the MLS with much promise. Everything one wants in a modern fullback appeared within the American.

When comparing the new player to his competitors for the starting left-back spot, he doesn’t offer anything totally different. If anything, he promises to be a more competent version of what they already have.

Jones remains one of the better attacking left-backs in MLS.

A threat to score or create from the wing, he can be that perfect mirror to Espinoza, as he was for Buchanan. Perhaps the one thing he brings to the table lacking from the rest of the competition is the ability to take defenders on.

Given that skillset, it seems highly likely that Jones becomes the starting left-back within the next few matches. It’s clear that Arena doesn’t trust his other options and brought in the US international to fulfill a role for him. Like much of the rest of the roster, players need to be sacrificed to fit Arena’s image.

Recent weeks continue to hammer home the point that this team needs defensive upgrades, and Jones doesn’t really bring that. To be fair to the new player, the left-back role hasn’t been their largest issue in the back. However, it begs the question of whether this move truly impacts the team and whether it was at all warranted?

Despite clearly being Arena’s top choice for the spot, this move jumbles up an already crowded position. If Costa left in the offseason, this makes sense, but by bringing in Jones, you sacrifice the development of Ricketts.


Noel Buck’s transfer appears to be much less straightforward than Jones’.

The former English international is still so young, but it seems that the Revolution willingly cut bait with him. 


Buck arrives in San Jose with a midfield that continues to play well. Despite preseason concerns, the duo of Harkes and Leroux brought stability to this team. The pair complements each other quite well, with Leroux exploding onto the scene.

Similar to Jones, Buck made his MLS debut under Arena. The hope for both player and manager clearly seems to be that Arena will unlock whatever potential exists within the player.

Again, similar to Jones, Buck joins a team that seems to have no real need for him. Even if you ignore the current starting midfield, this team has too many youngsters who need time. From Cruz Medina to Niko Tsakiris, Buck only complicates things for himself and his teammates.

Inconsistency both with his play and playing time plagued the youngster last season in New England, to the point that he became a bit player in 2025. Very much a per 90 player when looking at his stats, there’s enough to warrant a gamble on him. Clearly, Buck needs playing time, but can the team afford him the chance to develop?

Using per 90 stats, essentially a way to understand how his play translates to a full game, remains tricky for Buck. It shows that he is a decent passer, but not top-class, while offering very little on the defensive end. His positional fit also feels off, given his defensive struggles; nothing seems to show that he’s an upgrade from what they have currently.


Buying low seems to be the team’s plan when it comes to Buck.

This could be a fine strategy if the team had the minutes to offer him. 


To break out of this downward spiral, the Quakes need more than these two moves. Arena’s desire to replicate the Revolution with this Quakes team feels misguided.
Only a few of these moves have actually worked thus far, so what’s the point of continuing this trend?

PHOTO: San Jose Earthquakes/Facebook

Comments are closed.

Check Also

PREVIEW: All Eyes On Houston – Earthquakes Welcome Dynamo for Historic Home Playoff

Despite a 3-1 drubbing by Minnesota, the San Jose Earthquakes finished fourth and in high …