On Thursday, the Oakland A’s ceased to exist. Despite the fans fighting back and local media critiquing the situation, a team so entrenched in Oakland’s history ended its physical existence.
However, the memories forged in the Coliseum or on the BART Bridge will outlast whatever this team becomes.
“All wars are fought twice, the first time on the battlefield, the second time in memory.”
-Viet Thanh Nguyen
Explaining the East Bay to those who have never been is both difficult and worthwhile—a land full of contrasts that seemed ready to impact history forever.
It’s the same area that saw the rise of the Black Panthers and their vision of a more egalitarian future birthed in industrialization. An area so seemingly overshadowed by their neighbors across the Bay that most felt it strange to say you supported the East Bay in the center of all that was Oakland’s sports teams.
From the Warriors who foresaw the modern NBA in the Run-TMC era to the cultural juggernaut that represented Oakland in the Raiders, only the A’s truly won in Oakland. The Warriors struggled with relevance, and the Raiders’ stint in LA broke their bond to the East Bay, but the A’s won. Contrary to the modern image cultivated by the Fisher regime, this is a historic ballclub.
The A’s played the older annoying brother to the Giants, birthed icons of the game and gave the World a book and movie that dominates our lives. Most importantly, it gave East Bay a cultural cornerstone—one that it desperately needed.
Over the past decade, Oakland played the scapegoat.
The fans didn’t care. There was no money to make stadiums viable, so we had to leave.
While Oakland struggles with problems that plenty of cities have in the process of deindustrialization, it’s easier to highlight it in the context of the Bay Area. The 1960s and ‘70s brought ideas of change and hope that were dashed across the Bay. However, Oakland never received the boost that the South Bay, for example, did.
For opportunistic outsiders, it became easy to laugh off Oakland and its teams, but most easily, their fans.
Watch how the baseball media shifted over the past year. Before the A’s announced their move, people laughed at the crowd sizes, blaming the city. Now that they are leaving, the very same people are trying to show solidarity with fans.
But all this does is replace what made the A’s special. The culture built by the fans at that very same stadium is so often the butt of all jokes. A stadium showing the rot of a city abandoned by the rest of California and made home by the East Bay.
Compare the average experience of going to a game at Chase Center to one at the Coliseum. Chase represents the aura of the modern Bay Area, a stadium built in the shadows of colossal success. However, even as die-hard Warriors fans know, it’s soulless, a corporate conference center that occasionally has basketball.
For all its faults, the Coliseum allowed fans to build their own culture. From a tailgate experience unlike any other in MLB to bootleg tees for sale as fans walk in from BART, no modern stadium can replace this.
They cannot replace the feeling of thousands of fans cheering their team in a stadium built for the rapturous noise. No other stadium would have played home to the “sell the team” chants that became the anthem of the later Fisher years.
Oakland’s Coliseum acted as a nest where so many wonderful experiences became crucial memories. While on-field moments certainly played a part in those memories, the fondest ones are those of interactions with loved ones and fellow fans. As the hollowed-out husk of whatever the A’s now are begins their nomadic disaster, the Oakland A’s that represented a region are those to be remembered.
“You are dealing with forces, young man, when you speak of Wheat and the Railroads, not with men…Blame conditions, not men.”
-Frank Norris, The Octopus
In the years following the collapse of the Soviet Union, the oligarchs birthed by it acted out their wildest fantasies. Everything went up for sale as the region’s new rulers stripped everything down for the smallest glimmer of profit. As those at the top continued to reap the rewards, the workers and citizens of the new countries were left in the cold.
It’s not a one-to-one comparison, but that’s the modern model of all sports leagues: Sell all that you can while ensuring that players get the short end of the stick.
A’s players constantly need to answer for the sins of their owner while knowing that their contracts are playthings. Even if, in some universe, this Vegas move works, will the players get what their labor entails?

Not to absolve John Fisher, but this move and all that it comes with doesn’t happen without the support of MLB and the rest of the owners. Yes, they may see how the move unfolded as uncouth, but they never opposed it.
With baseball’s dwindling popularity and continuing revenue losses from the pandemic, MLB looks to sell out anything and everything. This means exploiting all revenue areas. Vegas, like an oasis, appears to be the final realization of this late-stage form of capitalism.
A death drive for profit spurned by increasingly shrinking venues. Oakland, in the league’s eyes, ran out of time to prove that it could be a true profit center. As the Raiders continue to show, you don’t need a fanbase in Vegas; the gimmick of having a team there will draw in tourists.
Fans never factored into the equation, thus making the decision at the highest level easy. The opportunity offered by Vegas meant more to them than any sort of tradition in Oakland.
While a few owners seemed willing to stop this move or at least oppose it, Fisher’s A’s never threatened them. Yes, the team got so close to actual sustained success, but at every point, the owner undermined the team. Marcus Semien’s departure highlights a willingness to self-sabotage in order to save a few pennies.
Just like with the Earthquakes and any other sports team, these organizations are playthings that drive profit. Removing naiveté makes you realize that anything and everything is a business. From insulin to the A’s, our system demands profit at all costs.
Fisher plays his role perfectly in this case by allowing his team to host the Vegas experiment. Should the team draw in their fair share for revenue sharing, the other owners will also be involved. Finally, there is the MLB as a whole, which wanted this and is seeing its plan through.
Despite the valorous fight by fans, it’s a fight that never challenged the real powers, the MLB.
It’s a battle against an organization that controls all aspects of a fight. So, the fight was rigged from the star.
However, something must be said about being willing to go down swinging as everything piled on top of fans. Fans showed that Oakland wasn’t the issue; it’s the lack of control that many feel over their lives.
All this acts as a reflection of the yelling into the void that modern life elicits. Powers that accumulate capital hold the true means of change. All we, and A’s fans, can do is show solidarity.
As the Oakland A’s die, they refuse to go out quietly. Their final game resembled more a celebration than a wake. For that, the World will remember Oakland as the city it is.
One unwilling to die quietly as the World continues to take from them.
If history happens first as tragedy, second as farce, then third must be hollow.
PHOTO: Oakland Athletics/Facebook



